The Institute of Ismaili Studies

The Institute of Ismaili Studies

Additions to the Site

Forthcoming Events

IIS Update

2013 News Archive

2012 News Archive

2011 News Archive

2010 News Archive

2009 News Archive

2008 News Archive

2007 News Archive

2006 News Archive

2005 News Archive

2004 News Archive

2003 News Archive

2002 News Archive

2001 News Archive

2000 News Archive

1999 News Archive

A  A  A  


Email this page Email this page

Print this Page Print this Page

Instant Search Plug-in

News & Events

Qur’anic Studies Lecture on Shi‘i Tafsir Classification and Sultan‘alishah’s Bayan al-Sa‘ada
October 2010

The Quranic Studies Unit of the IIS’ Department of Academic Research and Publications hosted an occasional lecture by Dr Alessandro Cancian, entitled ‘Shi‘i Tafsir Classification and Sultan ‘Ali Shah’s Bayan al-Saada’. Dr Cancian has now joined the Unit as a Research Associate in October 2010.

In his presentation, delivered in May 2010, Dr Cancian explained that hermeneutics play a crucial role in defining what a religion is and how it should be professed and practiced, which is demonstrated by the fact that virtually every religion has developed its own vast and articulate exegetical tradition. With regard to the relationship between authority and exegesis in Islam, he mentioned that the majority - if not all - of the most celebrated classical scholars played a role in Islam’s tradition of exegesis. He then summarised the history and types of tafasir.

Dr Cancian looked in more detail at the tafsir entitled Bayan al-Sa‘ada fi Maqamat al-‘Ibada, which he considers as marking an epoch in the history of modern Shi‘i Sufism, and deserving of more attention. Its author, Sultan ‘Ali Shah (1835-1909), of the Gonabadi branch of Ni‘matullahi Sufism, was a towering intellectual of his age in many respects, yet his writings are little known in Western academia and outside of the Persian speaking world. His tafsir is a comprehensive enterprise, as he was a mystic, philosopher and authorised mujtahid. Throughout, it is punctuated with juridical responses to challenging issues of his time, in-depth discussions of debated theological issues, and articulate scrutiny of technical themes of Sufism.

Dr Cancian noted that the wide circulation of the Bayan al-Saada among the followers of Shi‘i esotericism in Iran survived the political ups and downs of the 20th century. Despite the unsympathetic official attitude towards Sufi orders, its influence has not vanished. Sultan ‘Ali Shah, through his tafsir, has contributed to the perseverance and development of an entire exegetical tradition, whose roots are in classical medieval Sufism, Safavid hikmat-i ilahi, and the rich corpus of Shi’i riwayat.

In concluding his talk, Dr Cancian stated that the extent of Bayan al-Saada’s influence can only be appreciated against a systematic analysis of its textual consistency and its sources (primarily Sulami, Maybudi, the Mathnawi of Rumi, and Fayd Kashani). It is only through this analysis that a reliable portrait of the work’s key role as a hermeneutic bridge between the pre-modern and modern stages of Shi‘i mystical exegesis might be disclosed. Such a portrait would be an invaluable work that would open the way for new and promising lines in the study of mystical exegesis, and tafsir in general.

Related Pages on the IIS Website
  • News story on: New Researchers Join Qur’anic Studies Unit
  • News story on: Qur’anic Studies Lecture on Pragmatic Aspects of the Religious Text
  • Qur'anic Studies: Workshops, Seminars and Conferences


  • The Institute of Ismaili Studies - Qur’anic Studies Lecture on Shi‘i Tafsir Classification and Sultan‘alishah’s Bayan al-Sa‘ada
    Last updated: 10/12/2010 15:31